Tribute to Karen Bethea-Shields  

​​​

Karen Bethea-Shields has carved a distinguished path through North Carolina’s legal and civic history, marked by firsts, fearless advocacy, and a deep commitment to justice. Born Karen Galloway in 1949, she grew up in a segregated South and emerged as a formidable force for civil rights and gender equity. She earned her Bachelor of Arts degree in Psychology from East Carolina University. In 1974, she became one of the first Black women to graduate with a Juris Doctor from Duke University School of Law, an experience she endured with determination and purpose. Even before receiving her bar exam results, she was on the front lines of history, representing a case that would come to define her legacy.

​​

Her legal career began with extraordinary gravity when she was called to serve as co-counsel in the landmark case of State v. Joan Little, the first in U.S. history in which a woman successfully used deadly force in self-defense against sexual assault and was acquitted. At the age of 25 years old and fresh out of law school, Bethea-Shields stood at the center of a national storm that touched on race, gender, power, and justice. Representing Joan Little, a young Black woman accused of murdering a white jailer during an attempted rape, Bethea-Shields demonstrated courage, legal brilliance, and empathy. Her vivid closing argument in which she had jurors’ step “into Joan’s shoes” left the courtroom in tears and secured an acquittal that reverberated across the country.

​​

Despite being vilified by many in North Carolina at the time, Bethea-Shields remained steadfast in her belief that the courtroom must always be a place of truth and fairness. “We put the justice system on trial,” she said, unapologetically. For her work, she was named “Lawyer of the Year” in 1976 by the National Conference of Black Lawyers although accolades were never her motivation. Her compass was guided by her father’s words: “But for the hands of time, you could be in her shoes, and she could be in yours.”

​​

In 1980, she broke new ground again by becoming the first woman, and the first Black woman elected as a judge in North Carolina’s 14th Judicial District, serving Durham County. At just 30 years old, she stepped into the courtroom not only as a legal authority but as a symbol of progress and possibility. During her tenure, she introduced the Probation Challenge program, a bold initiative requiring adult and juvenile offenders to pursue their GEDs as part of their rehabilitation, reinforcing her belief in justice as a tool for personal transformation and education as a means of empowerment.

​​

Even as a judge, Bethea-Shields remained a public servant in the truest sense. She refused to let her career be a solitary achievement, instead channeling her influence to mentor others and speak openly about the structural inequities that pervade the legal system. She reminded audiences that true integration had not yet occurred insisting that mutual respect, not assimilation, is the bedrock of justice and equity. “If you’re only in it for yourself,” she often said, “you’re wasting your time.”

​​

After stepping down from the bench in 1986, Bethea-Shields returned to private practice, maintaining her focus on criminal law and continuing to serve marginalized populations. Her passion for the law, undimmed by time or challenge, continues to animate her life. Her clarity of purpose formed by personal conviction and trial by fire has made her an enduring figure in the legal profession and an inspiration to generations of advocates.

​​

Karen Bethea-Shields’ story is not just about shattering barriers; it's about reshaping the system itself from within. She remains a powerful reminder that the pursuit of justice is a daily act of courage, intellect, and empathy. Through her groundbreaking advocacy, judicial leadership, and lifelong service, she has left an indelible mark on North Carolina and the nation.